Here are my cocktail recipes and the cheese pairings for the class I taught at Murray's Cheese recently, which focused on holiday-themed cocktails of brown spirits wih fruit and spice infusions. We did five cocktails, each matched with a cheese. I was really happy with how well the cheeses paired with these drinks -- creating that "more than the sum of its parts" experience that is to my mind the goal in a pairing.
THE SEELBACH COCKTAIL
This classic recipe came from Jamie Boudreau in Imbibe magazine. The Seelbach is a classic champagne cocktail named after the Seelbach Hotel in Louisville, Kentucky. I elected to start the tasting with this one, as the bitters and the bubbly prick up the appetite. This is a great cocktail before a rich meal.
1 ounce bourbon (I used Buffalo Trace)
1/2 ounce triple sec (Cointreau or Luxardo are both good brands)
7 dashes Angostura bitters (or to taste)
7 dashes Peychaud bitters (or to taste)
3 ounces chilled NV champagne
Garnish: lemon twist
Add bourbon, triple sec, and bitters to ice-filled shaker and stir very well. Strain into chilled cocktail glass and top with champagne. Twist or flame a lemon twist over top, rub around rim, and drop in.
This was the hardest cocktail to pair. We ended up going for a sheep cheese that had a nice interaction with the bitters, popping them on the attack, but then finishing mellow and sweet:
MALVAROSA
First imported to the U.S. in August of 2004, Malvarosa began as a labor of love. To save the nearly extinct Guirra sheep, Valencian cheesemaker Enrique began producing this Manchego-like wheel. Frankly, we think it blows Manchego away. The paste is firm, but far more buttery, and incredibly rich and sweet. More like the crowd favorite Pyrenees Brebis, this one is compulsively edible, down to its nearly butterscotch finish. Aged for a minimum of three months; careful cheesemaking and gentle pasteurization preserve an enormous hit of succulent flavor.
RUSTY MENORAH
I knew I wanted to do a Scotch drink for the class, and I was playing around with Rob Roy variations, but they were all overwhelming the cheese. Then Kenta Goto at Pegu Club suggested I try a champagne-topped Rusty Nail. This was a great idea! I infused the Scotch with vanilla beans and bolstered the sweet honey flavor of the Drambuie with a syrup of New Zealand honey. This was my favorite drink of the bunch, a distinguished Hanukkah libation.
1 1/2 ounces Johnny Walker Black infused with vanilla bean
1/2 ounce Drambuie
1/2 ounce manuka honey syrup
3 ounces chilled NV Champagne
Garnish: orange twist
For infusion: steep 1L bottle of JWB with a large, plump vanilla bean for at least one week and up to one month, depending on desired strength
For honey syrup: mix equal parts manuka or other floral honey with spring water. Heat just to dissolve. Keep refrigerated.
For cocktail: in an ice-filled shaker, mix Scotch, Drambuie, and honey syrup. Stir very well and strain into chilled cocktail glass. Top with champagne and flame or twist orange rind over top.
This paired so well with the stinky yet mild Grayson:
MEADOW CREEK DAIRY GRAYSON
Virginia's Feete family uses ecologically-sound farming practices in raising their dairy herd of Jersey cows. No pesticides or herbicides are used in the fields where the cows are rotationally pastured. The cows are never confined or fed silage, and are given minimal hormones and antibiotics. The milking season ends when grass growth wanes and the cows wind down their milk production. The quality of the cheese reflects this diligence. Grayson is Meadow Creek Dairy's washed rind offering. The brownish-orange rind of the mildly pungent four-pound square envelopes a supple, semi-soft paste that tastes rich and beefy with sweet, nutty tones.
For the next two cocktails, I moved into brandy territory. The first one used a delicious homemade raspberry cordial that is great taken neat (so great that I almost didn't have enough left over for the cocktail). Mark Morris gave me the cordial recipe so I named the drink after my favorite of his dances.
L'ALLEGRO
The raspberry flavor is lifted up by the lemon juice in this bright-colored holiday cocktail. The black pepper rim adds a nice sharp note.
1 1/2 ounces raspberry-infused Armagnac
1/2 ounce Dubonnet rouge
1/2 ounce fresh-squeezed lemon juice
Garnish: black pepper sugar rim (3 parts organic white sugar mixed with 1 part fresh-ground black pepper)
For infusion: (Alice Waters’ recipe from Chez Panisse Fruit): Fill a 1-quart jar with raspberries. Pour in 1 cup sugar and cover with brandy or Cognac. Close the jar and let sit 4 days, shaking the jar occasionally to make sure that the sugar dissolves. Keeps 1 year.
Rub outside rim of chilled cocktail glass in lemon juice then coat with pepper-sugar mixture. Shake raspberry Armagnac, Dubonnet, and lemon juice very well over ice and strain into prepared glass.
The berry-peppery cocktail paired well with this fudgy-peppery cheese, and it reminded me of the best wine-cheese pairing I've ever enjoyed: a perfectly ripe Chaource with Billecart-Salmon NV rose.
JASPER HILL FARM CONSTANT BLISS
A truly exceptional new find: raw Ayrshire cow's milk, aged in caves for just 60 days. Unlike many bloomy cheeses, Constant Bliss is not sprayed with mold. The rind develops as the result of ambient molds in the cave. Hand-made by two brothers, Constant Bliss is buttery and dense, with an earthy, vegetal character. Some liken the mushroomy quality to a good Camembert, though the paste is dense and cakier. The aroma of the moist caves is present in the mottled gray and white rind.
I originally designed this next one with Grey Goose La Poire, but the apple flavor really comes through with Calvados. I love Benedictine as a sweetening agent in cocktails!
SUGARPLUM
Sweet and lightly fizzy, with Christmas-y flavors of cranberry, apple, and sweet spice.
1 1/2 ounces Calvados
1/3 ounce Benedictine
1/2 ounce Demerara spice syrup
7 cranberries
approx. 2 ounces sparkling cider such as Martinelli
Garnish: Apple chip (optional)
For Demerara syrup: Mix 1 C Demerara sugar, 1 C spring water, a cinnamon stick, six cloves, and three peppercorns in a saucepan, stirring to dissolve. Boil five minutes. Let cool, strain, and store refrigerated.
Muddle cranberries in the bottom of shaker with spice syrup. Add Benedictine and Calvados, fill shaker with ice, and shake very well. Strain into chilled cocktail glass (if flecks of cranberry bother you, fine strain) and top with chilled cider. Present with apple chip.
Since this cocktail is so full of true apple flavor, pairing with a great cheddar was a natural fit.
CABOT CLOTHBOUND CHEDDAR
We all know the name Cabot, but this first-to-market cheese represents a new commitment to American artisan cheesemaking. Using the pasteurized milk of Holstein cows from George Kempton neighboring farm in Peacham, Cabot produces these 35 pound clothbound wheels and delivers them to neighboring Jasper Hill Farm within 2 to 5 days for aging and maturation. Upon arrival, the Kehler brothers brush each wheel with melted lard to promote sturdy rind development and turn the cheese daily for three weeks. The wheels are then turned and brushed weekly as they develop alongside Jasper Hill's own cheese for 10-12 months. The resulting cheese offers a stunning array of flavors: the firm, slightly crunchy paste is never waxy, and unfolds with layers of toasted nut, toffee and cooked fruits.
I thought it would be nice to finish up with a hot toddy, so I went for hot buttered rum, and I had the students add their own butter from their cheese plates Of course Murray's sold some delicious, sweet cream butter.
VOLCANO HOUSE HOT BUTTERED RUM
This recipe adapted from Imbibe is a classic, dating from 1950s bartender Bob Ita of the Volcano House Hotel in Hawaii.
1 1/2 ounces aged rum
3/4 ounce lemon juice
1/4 ounce Maraschino
3/4 ounce Demerara syrup
Very hot black or oolong tea (I used Kuan Yin)
Garnish: one clove, small pat of unsalted butter
For Demerara syrup: Mix equal parts Demerara sugar and spring water. Stir over heat to dissolve. Let cool and store refrigerated.
Warm mug using boiling water. Combine rum, lemon juice, Maraschino, and sugar syrup in the bottom of the mug and stir to dissolve. (If you want a piping-hot drink, stir these together over a low flame until warm, then pour in preheated mug.) Top with very hot tea, stir, and float butter and clove on top.
Since the funky cherry pit flavor of the Maraschino comes through strongly in this cocktail, our cheese
pairing for this one was a nod to the flavors of the
classic cheese fondue, in which gruyere and kirsch (cherry brandy) are
common partners.
BEELER GRUYERE
Undoubtedly the best Gruyère we’ve ever come across! Selected by Swiss Maitre Fromager Rolf Beeler, a lengthy 18 months of aging produces a dark rind that speaks to its firm, nutty, intensified paste of raw cow's milk, dotted with crystallization. A little goes a long way; just a whiff could satisfy you.