My high school English teacher Kristine very generously gave me and my husband tickets to see Hamlet at the Armory, playing through August in repertory with the Oresteia. She did this after reading the New Yorker preview, a brilliant piece of sell side journalism that manages to lure Shakespeare fans without actually saying the show will be any good. Even though it is gauche to criticize a gift, I feel I owe my teacher a report...
Five minutes in, Ethan leaned over and whispered, “I love it so far!”
I said, “Me too!”
That was the high point of the show. Director Robert Icke is known for innovation, and he sets the play in a dystopian modern Denmark in which watchmen buzz in through security gates and the ghost haunts a bank of screens. So far, so good. The tech illuminated the way everything happening to the first family had vast ramifications for the nation. There were fun CNN-style reports of Fortinbras’s campaigns and a stylish Olympics treatment of the final fencing match with Laertes.
Contributing to the great beginning were Hara Yannis as Bernardo and Michael Abubakar as Marcellus. Such technical strength in relatively minor roles – as well as gender and racial diversity – was promising, but unfortunately the rest of the cast was uneven. Thank God for Angus Wright as Claudius or we might have left during one of the two intermissions.
It’s previews yet, and Lia Williams, the original Gertrude, had to back out due to Achilles tendinitis, a huge blow that is likely still rocking the production. Jennifer Ehle is doing a great job as a late replacement, but she still feels like she’s in a different play.
Alex Lawther makes a tiny, Justin Bieber-y Hamlet. It’s interesting casting but hard to believe he is capable of defeating Norwegians and also hard to listen to all those monologues. His halting, emo delivery kills the rhythm and drags out the run time to nearly four hours.
Ethan: “I didn’t understand a lot of what he said.”
Kirsty Rider is lovely but can’t push through the bad choices. Icke told the New Yorker that he shifted the order of the opening scenes to bring Ophelia out earlier and give more weight to the love plot. This means Hamlet goes right from his first grief-struck soliloquy to humping Ophelia on a couch, which he then hides behind, where he overhears Laertes’s parting advice. Laertes delivers this speech in an ironic manner, like he knows his sister’s “chaste treasure” has already been passed around.
All this makes no sense. If Ophelia is sexually liberated and Hamlet knows her family is trying to cock block him, what obstacle is there to their intimacy? I think we’re supposed to say, class anxiety. Peter Wight is wonderful as Polonius, utterly unfazed by the famous lines, playing it all a little bit straight as an anxious courtier trying to shore up his own position. But I did not believe this Gossip Girl version of Ophelia would have obeyed him or cared enough about him to go bat shit crazy when he dies.
Ophelia is always problematic. It’s hard to tell if the role is misogynistic or a portrait of misogyny.
Paul Griffiths wrote an experimental novel “Let Me Tell You” composed only of the 483 words Ophelia speaks in the play. It’s a haunting little book:
“So: now I come to speak. At last. I will tell you all I know. I was deceived to think I could not do this. I have the powers; I take them here. I have the right. I have the means. My words may be poor, but they will have to do.”
The Wooster Group solved the problem in their fabulous post-modern fashion, double casting Kate Valk as both Gertrude and Ophelia. When she was Ophelia, Valk wore a blonde wig and declaimed her lines over an alt rock soundtrack. It was funny and also really good original music that I experienced as a kind of stand-in for Ophelia's sexual power.
The sound design and music in the Icke version was just awful. I think they did a Google search for classic rock songs with castles in them.
Ethan: “This is like the music you’d hear in an Applebee’s.”
Turning the final scene into a sports broadcast was another great idea, but the emotional impact of the deaths was completely undercut by having all the actors rise and join hands at the end as though reunited on a dance floor in heaven. I was sad that I wasn't more sad, but I was relieved there were no more monologues.
As we exited the gorgeous Armory, I told Ethan I would give the show a B-.
He accused me of grading on a curve because it was Hamlet.
I said of course I was grading on a curve because it was Hamlet!
I will always go out and see Hamlet, anywhere, anytime. I would see it in a boat. I would see it with a goat. I prefer when it is free but I would see it for a fee. I would see it in the rain, or in the dark, or on a train, or even at the Armory again. In fact, I'm going back for the Oresteia. Ham I am.